top of page

A Step in the Right Direction: Judge Benitez Strikes Down California's Ammunition Laws

In a significant victory for Second Amendment advocates, U.S. District Judge Roger T. Benitez has once again delivered a blow to California's stringent gun control laws. This time, he struck down a state statute that imposed background checks on every ammunition sale while prohibiting residents from bringing ammunition purchased outside the state back home. Affectionately known as "Saint Benitez" among California gun owners, the judge has consistently championed the text and tradition of the Second Amendment, bringing about changes in the state's gun control landscape.

California has long been at the forefront of implementing strict gun control measures, and ammunition restrictions were no exception. The state statute in question mandated background checks for every ammunition sale, creating hurdles for law-abiding citizens and restricting their access to essential self-defense tools. Additionally, residents were prohibited from bringing ammunition purchased outside the state back home, further limiting their rights.

Judge Benitez's Decision:

In a 32-page decision, Judge Benitez not only struck down the ammunition-related statute but also declared it a violation of both the Second Amendment and the Constitution's dormant Commerce Clause. The judge argued that none of the statutes presented by California's Attorney General represented a historic analogue to the state's modern ammunition prohibition. Moreover, he emphasized that at the time of the Second Amendment's ratification, there were no laws imposing background checks on either gun purchases or ammunition acquisitions.

A Second Victory for Second Amendment Rights:

This recent decision marks the second time Judge Benitez has reached a similar conclusion regarding California's restrictive gun laws. The Ninth Circuit had previously sent the case back to him for reconsideration after the Supreme Court's decision in the Bruen case. Judge Benitez, known for his unwavering commitment to the Constitution, adhered to the text, history, and tradition of the Second Amendment in both rulings.

Implications and a Glimpse into the Future:

The significance of this decision goes beyond California's borders. It sends a clear message that the judiciary is scrutinizing the constitutionality of gun control measures and emphasizing the importance of aligning with the principles laid out in the Second Amendment. While Judge Benitez hinted that a voter-approved initiative for ammunition purchase permits might have survived constitutional scrutiny, the laws enacted by California lawmakers did not.

As "Saint Benitez" continues to uphold the principles enshrined in the Second Amendment, today's victory is undoubtedly a step in the right direction. The decision reinforces the idea that laws infringing upon the rights of law-abiding citizens will be scrutinized and challenged in the pursuit of preserving individual freedoms. This victory serves as a beacon of hope for Second Amendment advocates, signaling that the fight for constitutional rights is making progress, one legal battle at a time.


72 views0 comments


Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page